Artificial intelligence (AI) is changing the way people access information, communicate and make decisions. However, using AI during a personal injury compensation claim in NSW can create significant legal and practical risks, particularly when confidential information is involved. In this edition of Advantage Legal’s ‘Compensation Insider’ series, we explain the risks of using AI in NSW Compulsory Third Party (CTP) claims, how it can affect confidentiality, legal professional privilege, evidence and legal costs, and why speaking directly with your personal injury lawyer remains essential to protecting your compensation rights.
SHOULD YOU USE AI FOR YOUR PERSONAL INJURY CLAIM?
AI can be useful for researching general legal information and understanding unfamiliar terminology. However, there’s a significant difference between researching NSW CTP law and relying on AI to interpret legal advice or make decisions about your individual claim.
Your solicitor considers how the accident occurred, your injuries, medical evidence, employment circumstances, economic losses and future needs. They also develop a legal strategy based on your circumstances and the available evidence.
AI may provide you with information that doesn’t apply to your situation. It can also produce convincing but entirely incorrect answers, sometimes called AI ‘hallucinations’. Relying on those answers may create misunderstandings, unnecessary disputes and decisions that affect your compensation entitlements.
CAN USING AI COMPROMISE CONFIDENTIALITY IN A NSW CTP CLAIM?
Confidentiality is one of the greatest risks associated with public AI platforms. Medical reports, legal advice, correspondence, financial records and information about your case strategy may contain highly sensitive information. Uploading these documents or discussing their contents with a public AI platform may expose information that would otherwise remain confidential. Depending on the platform and its settings, information may be stored, retained or disclosed. It could potentially become accessible to another party, including an insurer, its investigators or lawyers, if made publicly available or required to be produced through a subpoena or court, tribunal or commission order. Information entered into public AI systems may therefore no longer remain exclusively within your control.
CAN AI COMPROMISE LEGAL PROFESSIONAL PRIVILEGE?
Legal professional privilege protects certain confidential communications and documents created for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice or use in litigation. Sharing privileged information with an external AI platform may compromise that protection, depending on the circumstances. For example, uploading your solicitor’s advice and asking AI to identify weaknesses in your case could disclose confidential information about your legal strategy.
Privilege is not automatically waived simply because AI has been used. However, unnecessary disclosure can create risks that are difficult to reverse. Before sharing confidential legal information with a public AI platform, speak with your solicitor.
WHAT IF AI IS CONNECTED TO YOUR EMAIL OR COMPUTER SOFTWARE?
These risks aren’t limited to AI websites. AI assistants are increasingly integrated into email accounts, word-processing applications and other everyday software. Depending on their permissions and configuration, these systems may access, analyse or process confidential legal correspondence and documents. For example, an AI assistant connected to your personal email account may have access to communications between you and your solicitor.
Not all AI systems operate identically, and some have stronger confidentiality protections than others. However, you should understand what information the system can access, where it is stored and how it is used. Avoid allowing public AI tools to access confidential information about your claim without first discussing the implications with your solicitor.
SHOULD YOU USE AI TO PREPARE INSTRUCTIONS FOR YOUR SOLICITOR?
Your solicitor needs to understand what you remember, what you understand and what you want to achieve from your case. This becomes particularly important following an accident involving a traumatic brain injury or cognitive difficulties. Solicitors may need to assess whether their clients have the capacity to understand legal advice and provide valid instructions. Where instructions are generated or substantially influenced by AI, distinguishing a client’s genuine understanding and decisions from computer-generated material can become difficult.
Using AI does not establish that someone lacks mental capacity. However, it may complicate a solicitor’s assessment of their client’s understanding and intentions. Important legal instructions should come directly from you, not an AI-generated response.
CAN AI PREPARE WITNESS STATEMENTS OR EXPERT MEDICAL EVIDENCE?
NSW courts and the Personal Injury Commission have introduced specific restrictions governing AI-generated evidence. In Personal Injury Commission proceedings, generative AI must not be used to generate or rephrase the substance of witness evidence. Your statement must reflect your own recollection and knowledge.
Expert reports are also subject to restrictions and disclosure requirements. AI cannot independently replace the professional opinion of a qualified medical expert. Accurate evidence is essential to establishing your injuries, their connection to the accident and their ongoing consequences.
CAN FALSE AI-GENERATED INFORMATION AMOUNT TO FRAUD?
AI sometimes produces convincing information that is factually incorrect, including events, details or references that never existed. If inaccurate information enters your claim, it may affect your credibility or create disputes about your evidence.
There are also serious consequences for knowingly providing false information. The Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW) contains provisions which makes it an offence to provide information concerning a motor accident or claim knowing it is materially false or misleading. The maximum penalty is 500 penalty units, two years’ imprisonment, or both.
An innocent AI-generated mistake does not automatically constitute fraud. However, knowingly submitting materially false or misleading information can expose someone to criminal penalties. You remain responsible for ensuring the information you provide about your claim is truthful and accurate.
CAN USING AI INCREASE YOUR LEGAL COSTS?
Although AI can save time, using it incorrectly may increase legal costs. Clients sometimes use AI to interpret legal advice, prepare lengthy emails or generate arguments about compensation entitlements. Where this information is inaccurate, irrelevant or inconsistent with the evidence, solicitors must spend additional time reviewing it, correcting misunderstandings and clarifying instructions. Depending on the applicable costs arrangements, this may increase legal expenses. Often, a direct conversation with your solicitor is a more efficient and cost effective way to resolve questions about your claim.
WHY SHOULD YOU SPEAK DIRECTLY WITH YOUR PERSONAL INJURY LAWYER?
Every NSW CTP claim is different. Your solicitor understands your injuries, evidence, financial circumstances and the legal strategy relevant to your case. Unlike AI, your solicitor can consider your individual circumstances, explain your options and take professional responsibility for their advice.
At Advantage Legal, we encourage clients to ask questions, raise concerns and seek clarification whenever something is unclear from both a rehabilitation and claim perspective. AI may assist with general research, but it should not replace direct communication with a trusted legal advisor.
Your personal injury compensation claim is personal. Protect your confidential information, protect your case strategy and speak directly with someone who understands you and your circumstances.
NEED ASSISTANCE WITH A CTP CLAIM IN NSW?
At Advantage Legal, we practice rehabilitation-focused compensation law, meaning we prioritise your recovery while protecting your compensation entitlements. You’ll deal directly with an experienced personal injury lawyer who understands the CTP claim process and how CTP insurers operate. We offer no-win, no-fee billing and arrange for payment of your disbursements such as specialist medical reports and clinical notes to ensure that there is no financial burden on you throughout your claim.
If you’d like clarity about your claim, your timeframes, or your next steps, we’re here to help.
This article is for educational purposes only and should not be relied upon as legal or financial advice. Readers should be aware that compensation law and policy documentation changes regularly and may impact the accuracy of the information contained within this article, which is current as at 1 November 2026. Any person relying on the information contained within this article does so at their own risk.












